Blue eyes are captivating and have a certain allure that makes them stand out. If you have blue eyes, you have a unique canvas to work with when it comes to applying eyeshadow. The right eyeshadow can enhance your eye color, making them even more striking and beautiful.
In this article, we will explore the top 10 best eyeshadows for blue eyes in 2024. Whether you prefer a natural look or want to experiment with bold and vibrant colors, we have got you covered. Let's dive in!
1. Best Overall Eyeshadows for Blue Eyes: Maybelline The Nudes Eyeshadow Palette
Maybelline The Nudes Eyeshadow Palette
Every blue-eyed beauty needs a warm, nude eyeshadow palette in their makeup bag, and Maybelline The Nudes is the ideal choice. This versatile palette features 12 eyeshadow shades that can be combined in countless ways to create different looks. From natural and everyday makeup to smokey eyes and soft-glam looks, this palette has got you covered.
The shades that work best for enhancing blue eyes include warm gold, peachy champagne, bronze, taupe, black, beige, and gray. These shades help intensify the blue color and add depth to your eye makeup. The palette also offers a Blushed version with a cooler, pink-leaning color story that looks softer against blue eyes.
While some of the matte shades may not be extremely pigmented, they are still workable and forgiving, especially for beginners. If you prefer intensely dark, matte looks, we recommend trying the Milani Most Loved Mattes Palette. Overall, Maybelline The Nudes Eyeshadow Palette is a must-have for blue-eyed beauties who want a versatile and affordable option.
2. Best Budget Eyeshadows for Blue Eyes: Wet n Wild Color Icon Eyeshadow Palette
Wet n Wild Color Icon Eyeshadow Palette
For those looking for an affordable and playful twist on eyeshadow for blue eyes, the Wet n Wild Color Icon Eyeshadow Palette is an excellent choice. This palette offers 10 shades with warm nudes, peaches, and blues, adding a fun and unique touch to your eye makeup.
The palette includes basic matte nudes for a natural look, stunning matte and frost shades in the orange/peach family for colorful looks that bring out the blue in your eyes, and a shimmery blue-teal shade that mimics your eye color. This shade adds refreshing contrast to warm eyeshadows and makes your entire look more compelling and unique.
One standout feature of this palette is that Wet n Wild considered how eyeshadow colors are actually used. The medium transition shades come in larger sizes, ensuring they last longer. The deeper transition color can even double as a bronzer, adding versatility to the palette.
While the frost shades require a bit more attention during application, the overall quality and pigmentation of this palette are impressive. If you prefer a more subdued and affordable option, the Revlon ColorStay Quad is worth considering.
3. Best Premium Eyeshadows for Blue Eyes: LORAC PRO Palette 2 Eyeshadow Kit
LORAC PRO Palette 2 Eyeshadow Kit
When it comes to eyeshadow quality, LORAC is hard to beat. The LORAC PRO Palette 2 Eyeshadow Kit offers 16 buttery and highly pigmented shades that are incredibly easy to blend and build up. This palette features a cool and neutral color story, making it a perfect match for blue eyes, especially if you have cool undertones in your skin.
One standout shade in this palette is Rosé, a soft golden-pink shade that brightens blue eyes like a copper shade without the intense warmth that can clash against cool-toned skin. The palette offers a mix of frosted and matte shades, including fun but wearable colors like plum, jade, and navy.
The LORAC PRO Palette 2 provides ample opportunities to create both smokey and natural looks. It also comes with LORAC's fantastic eyeshadow primer, adding value to this premium purchase. The only shade missing is a dark chocolate brown or espresso, but this palette is a sophisticated addition to any eyeshadow collection.
If you prefer a more basic premium eyeshadow palette for blue eyes, LORAC's Unzipped or the original PRO Palette might be more suitable options.
4. Most Colorful Eyeshadow: NYX Ultimate Shadow Palette
NYX Ultimate Shadow Palette
Don't be afraid to rock bright and colorful eyeshadow if you have blue eyes! While this article focuses on conventional colors that enhance blue eyes, it's important to have the option to go all-out with color as well. The NYX Ultimate Shadow Palette offers all the bright eyeshadows you could possibly want without being overwhelming.
This palette features 16 vivid colors in both matte and satin finishes, offering a wide range of options for creating various looks. You can add a pop of neon to a neutral look with a palette like Maybelline's The Nudes, create a vibrant rainbow look, or go for an editorial monochromatic look. The possibilities are endless.
The pigmentation of these shadows is high, and they blend well with metallic shades without creating a massive contrast in texture. To achieve maximum intensity and pigmentation, it's recommended to use them over an eyeshadow primer.
If you're looking for bold and colorful eyeshadows to make your blue eyes pop, the NYX Ultimate Shadow Palette is a perfect choice.
5. Best Eyeshadow for Mature Blue Eyes: Milani Bold Obsessions Eyeshadow Palette
Milani Bold Obsessions Eyeshadow Palette
Matte eyeshadows are a great option for mature blue eyes, as they are less likely to emphasize any texture on the eyelids. The Milani Bold Obsessions Eyeshadow Palette offers 12 cool and warm earthy tones in a matte finish, making it an excellent choice for mature blue eyes.
The shade range includes plums, pinks, peaches, and burnt oranges that create softly flattering looks and emphasize blue eyes. The pigmentation of these matte shades is exceptional, and they have a soft, creamy texture that is more suitable for delicate mature skin.
It's important to note that matte eyeshadows can be enjoyed by anyone, regardless of age. This palette can be used alone or in combination with shimmers or other textures to create a variety of eye makeup looks.
If you're ready to explore matte eyeshadows and want a palette specifically designed to complement mature blue eyes, the Milani Bold Obsessions Eyeshadow Palette is a perfect choice.
6. Best Stick Eyeshadow: Julep Eyeshadow 101 Crème to Powder Stick
Julep Eyeshadow 101 Crème to Powder Stick
Cream eyeshadows offer a convenient and quick way to glam up your eyes, especially if you lead a busy lifestyle . The Julep Eyeshadow 101 Crème to Powder Stick is a fantastic choice for those who prefer cream eyeshadows.
These cream-to-powder sticks have a soft and velvety texture, making them easy to apply and blend. The pigmentation is medium, allowing for a softer makeup look. They come in 24 shades, including both shimmer and matte options.
For blue eyes, shades like Copper Shimmer, Champagne, and Warm Gold are perfect for highlighting and adding depth. The longevity of these eyeshadow sticks is impressive, and they can also double as eyeliners for a soft smokey look.
The Julep Eyeshadow 101 Crème to Powder Sticks are perfect for on-the-go application. The packaging is sleek and convenient, and these sticks don't require a sharpener. They even come with a smudger to help blend and smoke out your eyeshadow.
7. Best Eyeshadow for Beginners: Revlon ColorStay 16hr Eyeshadow Quad
The Revlon ColorStay 16hr Eyeshadow Quad is an excellent choice for beginners who want to experiment with eyeshadow. This compact palette features four powder eyeshadows with a pretty frost finish.
The color story of this palette is light, offering two highlight shades, a gold shade for the lid, and a medium brown for the crease. These shades are neutral and can be worked into various makeup looks. The gold shade, in particular, adds a warm touch that softly emphasizes blue eyes.
While this quad may not create a dramatic effect, it adds a bit of "oomph" and polish to your makeup without overwhelming your look. The colors blend easily and can be used to create soft smokey eyes or classic eyeshadow shapes.
The low pigmentation of these shadows makes them forgiving for beginners who tend to apply too much product. If you're new to makeup or looking to give someone a makeup gift, the Revlon ColorStay 16hr Eyeshadow Quad is an excellent choice.
8. Best Eyeshadow Singles: Anastasia Beverly Hills Eyeshadow Singles
Anastasia Beverly Hills Eyeshadow Singles
If you prefer to create your own eyeshadow palette or want to have complete control over your shade selection, the Anastasia Beverly Hills Eyeshadow Singles are the way to go. These eyeshadow singles offer the same high quality and pigmentation as the brand's popular palettes.
Available in a wide range of shades and finishes, including matte, shimmer, and metallic options, these singles allow you to customize your eye makeup looks to suit your preferences. Shades like Realgar, a neutral brown with a strong orange undertone, work especially well with blue eyes and complement other flattering shades like peach or rose gold.
The eyeshadow singles are technically refills meant to be pressed into an existing palette or compact, making them eco-friendly. However, they may not be convenient if you don't already have a refillable or magnetic palette.
If you want to create your own unique eyeshadow palette tailored to your blue eyes, the Anastasia Beverly Hills Eyeshadow Singles are a perfect choice.
9. Best Cream Eyeshadow: L’Oreal Paris Infallible 24HR Shadow
The L’Oreal Paris Infallible 24HR Shadow offers a slightly more intense cream eyeshadow option for blue eyes. These shadow pots blend the best qualities of a powder and cream formula, resulting in a soft and velvety texture.
The shades in this range are highly pigmented and self-set beautifully, providing better longevity than traditional cream eyeshadows. Shades like Endless Sea, a stunning iridescent teal, add a unique touch to blue eyes, especially when paired with warm-toned eyeshadows for contrast.
The range also includes other shades that suit blue eyes well, such as the coppery Amber Rush and Glistening Garnet, a warm magenta. The metallic shadows in this range are particularly stunning, while the matte shades may require a bit more effort to build up and blend.
Due to their jar packaging, these cream eyeshadows are not as quick and easy to apply as stick or powder shadows. However, their effectiveness as eyeshadow primers adds value, and they can also be used as eyeliners for a soft smokey look.
10. Best Vegan Eyeshadow: Pacifica Pink Nudes Mineral Eyeshadows
Pacifica Pink Nudes Mineral Eyeshadows
For those who prefer vegan eyeshadows, the Pacifica Pink Nudes Mineral Eyeshadows are an excellent choice. This palette offers 10 shades with cool nudes and pinks, creating a soft and romantic eye makeup look. The formula is also talc-free and free from other controversial ingredients, appealing to clean beauty enthusiasts.
While the pigmentation of these shadows is medium, they can be built up for more intensity. The texture is a bit chalky, so it's important to be careful during application to avoid fallout. However, for those who prioritize clean and vegan formulas, these minor inconveniences are worth it.
The Pacifica Pink Nudes palette includes neutral browns that work well for highlighting and filling in eyebrows. It's a versatile palette suitable for both beginners and those with more experience. If you're looking for frosted eyeshadows with a clean formula, the Crystal Matrix palette from the same range is worth considering.
In conclusion, finding the right eyeshadows for blue eyes is all about enhancing their natural beauty and creating eye-catching looks. Whether you prefer warm nudes, vibrant colors, or matte finishes, there is an eyeshadow palette or single out there that will suit your preferences. Experiment with different shades and textures to discover the perfect eyeshadow look for your blue eyes.
